Wednesday, May 31, 2017

Why Unofficial Biopics Should Remain Unproduced





Today I am slightly breaking some cardinal film blogging rules. Some of the films I am going to refer to I have not seen in their entirety, mainly, because frankly, no one should. Biographical films or "biopics" as they are commonly referred to today can be some of the most impactful pieces of cinema when done properly. In my post, you'll see me use terms like "done properly" quite often. The truth is this kind of phrase is subjective. What some find to be fine art, others will see as utter garbage; look at the current state of the White House for further proof of this notion. More often than not, we qualify a film as "good" by the mass critical reception it receives. Critics aren't always right, but average viewers like myself often have our finger on the pulse of decent quality cinema or television. When thousands or even millions of our opinions seem to reach a consensus, I personally believe it's pretty safe to assume a film or television show is what we see it to be. So to circle back to my original point here, what do most everyday people think of biopics?


The popular TV Channel Lifetime is the main culprit on trial here as they have inspired me to write this hopefully somewhat concise rant. With the release of last night's Searching for Neverland (2017), a Michael Jackson biopic I have simply lost patience with the lack of propriety this channel has in regards to the material it chooses to handle. Let me say, first and foremost, that if the individual whose life is the subject of the film does not grant you permission, or in the case that they are deceased, their family and/or estat, you should NOT pursue a cinematic adaptation of their life or story. According to social media, Michael Jackson, in this television picture, somehow magically acquired a British accent not heard of until now. Possibly because the actor (or rather an impersonator) portraying him did not feel the need to put much work in masking it in order to more accurately and respectfully portray the King of Pop, these films might as well be straight up fiction with a thinly written protagonist that not-so-ambiguously mirrors their real-life counterparts. That would be slightly less offensive than the subpar incredibly offensive and inaccurate biopics Lifetime has been excreting over the last several years. I could not watch Britney Ever After in its entirety, though I watched the majority of its convoluted running time. As both a fan of Ms Spears and someone with a fully functioning brain, honestly, I wouldn't say I liked the blatant disregard for a human's fragile psyche and complicated personal strife. Films like this very simply, have no heart. They thrive and rely on one single thing to live, nostalgia. People will watch because of their familiarity with the subject matter. Maybe they watch because they detest the subject matter and want to see it treated poorly for kicks. Cinematic fetishism aside, these films lose their audience before the title even appears on the screen. Both the Britney and Michael biopics could not even receive the music rights of the artists they were portraying. What is the point of crudely attempting to illustrate these superstar's lives if you aren't even going to show the talent that made them famous in the first place?! From a business standpoint, it is astounding that this message has not yet been received. These films cause legal issues, loss in viewership and make little to no money in after-sales on DVD or digital platforms. They are dead in the water and yet Lifetime continues to give stillbirth to them and shows no signs of slowing down.

Now some of these biopics are handled with some semblance of care or consideration for the subject matter. Whitney (2015) the story of Whitney Houston and Bobby Brown's tumultuous marriage was directed by Houston's friend and former co-star, Angela Basset. It is no surprise that it took a female African American director to finally imbue one of these tawdry biopics with some form of class and respect for the subject matter. However, seeing that her family were less than pleased with the biopic proves that Lifetime still has a way to go in creating both entertaining and respectful biographical stories for some of the biggest titans in the entertainment industry. I'm not ignorant, I know Britney Spears is not Harvey Milk or Erin Brockovich, but she and others still have a right to have their stories told with some speck of humility in them. Will Lifetime learn their lesson? In my honest opinion, no. They could care less about credibility. They are a manufacturing factory and will continue to assembly line personal stories which deserve much more tender attention and care with hasty indifference. In the era of nostalgia fever and remake influenza running rapid in both the big and small screen, these misguided television executives and filmmakers think they've cashed in on audience's ignorance to reality and their apparent apathy toward real human trauma. Prove them wrong, don't tune in; I certainly will not be anymore. Whether it's Fuller House or the Unauthorized Full House, people should let a legacy live on, but not die from a heart attack of creative cholesterol filled disaster!


A quick note about the big screen biopics: it was recently announced that Universal Pictures had secured the rights to a Madonna biopic titled Blonde Ambition which was voted the #1 script on this past year's Blacklist. I had the privilege of reading the script in my screenwriting class this semester. While I enjoyed the script on a personal level and found its structure to be impeccable in design, I never believed it would get greenlit. I knew Madonna would never approve. Alas, it has, and she indeed does not. If the film fails to receive the music rights to her music, I firmly believe it should not be pursued on the same basis of morality and decency that I have mentioned above. Tell your own stories, not your perverted or bias versions of other peoples.

Thursday, March 23, 2017

Beauty and the Beast (2017): A Tale Retold with Time




I've been waiting with stifled anticipation for the last two years for Disney's live-action reimagining of one of it's most classic cinematic masterpieces Beauty and The Beast (1991), to come to theaters. Having gotten the privilege to see it on opening night with my mother and father, I found myself once more immersed into a world of fantasy and childhood nostalgia. The film boasts an incredibly talented cast and the script by Evan Spiliotopoulos and Stephen Chbosky hits all the old story marks, while even finding the time to create new moments for us to treasure forever: if you've listened to the new soundtrack, you'll find the pun in that sentence. The film is not altogether perfect, nor does it in any way surpass its timeless animated predecessor. It at times falters, unsure of where it should lie, somewhere between a childhood fairytale and an adult progressive message about the changing times. In my opinion, it could've done both with a far better tonal balance had it not been so self-conscious. I shall split this review up into several subsections, similar to the format of my review for the Blair Witch (2016).

The Cast

The formidable ensemble of this film is one not to be undervalued. Emma Watson, Dan Stevens, Emma Thompson, Ewan McGregor amongst many others breathe life into these roles we've so desperately missed since the 1990s. An important note to also make early on in this review is that everyone in this film can sing. Emma's voice ironically may be the weakest among the group, but it's light and wilting and appropriate for the delicate, yet willful character she portrays. In fact, let's talk about Ms Watson's performance and get it out of the way. I am sad to report that I personally found her lacking in this lead role, not necessarily in talent as much as execution. In several key scenes, Watson comes up short of anything resembling emotional resonance. As the Beast begins to beguile her with his charm and hidden depth, she seems to be going through the motions rather than experiencing an actual transformation of comprehension and insight. When she tells the dying Beast lying in her arms that she loves him, her face restrains instead of succumbing to heartache as it so should. Her saving grace comes in a newly added subplot in which she and the Beast visit her former childhood home in Paris to discover what happened to her mother. Watson's reaction to the sacrifices Belle's parent's made for her feels raw, real and even frighteningly relatable to anyone whose parents have suffered a minute to spare their child a lifetime. Opposite Watson, Dan Stevens puts on a formidable and dashing performance as The Beast. The script opens up his character to new opportunities like Watson's, but Stevens seems to take more chances with his freedom. He is menacing when needed and surprisingly vulnerable and endearing when least expected. He handles his new solo Evermore with aplomb and possesses the vigor of a true stage performer. Gugu Mbatha - Raw is wasted unfortunately in the role of the maid turned feather duster, Plumette. An accomplished singer and actress should have more to do than fly around as a bird and put on a ludicrous French accent while spitting out a few lines of dialogue here and there. She starred in the film Belle (2013) for heaven sakes! The same cannot be said for Audra McDonald, who of course is given an expanded supporting role and plenty of opportunities to flex her unquestionably magnificent vocal cords. Josh Gad is memorable as Le Fou, but the controversial sexuality of his character comes off more as a cheap highlighted stereotype than a cinematic breakthrough, nice try Disney. The rest of the cast round out their roles nicely, bringing relatively the same amount of energy to the characters as there was in the 1991 animated feature.

The Soundtrack

What is a musical without good music? The answer is the abomination that is From Justin to Kelly (2003). Luckily, Beauty and The Beast had the clarity of mind enough to bring back Alan Menken and Time Rice as composers and producers, as well as utilize some unused material from the late great Howard Ashman. The music to Beauty and The Beast should whisk the audience away into a magical world of love and adventure. The songs on the new soundtrack do whisk the audience away, though sometimes it is only with a light breeze. The opening song "Belle" for example comes off as underwhelming and seriously lacking in the boisterous energy the original had given life to. "Be Our Guest" is given dazzling new effects and choreography, to much joyous, if not epileptic-like effect. The title song (my favorite song of the original) is given due justice by the incomparable Emma Thompson, who sustains a cockney British accent without faltering a note or missing a beat. Her rendition of the title song is as enchanting and passionate as her dear friend Angela Lansbury had sung it before her. The new songs fair well, though they are not exactly on par with the gems of the original. They are just good enough to be set beside these other timeless classics. The best of the three new additions is "How Does A Moment Last Forever" sung by various characters throughout the film and finally in its entirety in the film's credits by Celine Dion. This song echoes the Disney of the past decade, decadent, universal and engrossing. Some may argue it is trying too hard, but I believe it tries just enough. Overall the soundtrack does not surpass the original but breathes a fresh perspective on these timely treasured tunes of old. You'll still have a pip in your step and a song in your heart, even if you may want to regurgitate it after a few listens.

The Plot

Director Bill Condon and his competent screenwriters help flesh out this tale as old as time into something even more substantial and cinematically pleasurable. They add a touch of logic, which may seem absurd for a fairytale, but is actually a welcomed inclusion here as it raises the stakes for many of the characters. The curse the Enchantress puts on the castle extends to the village itself, wiping away all memories of the castle and its inhabitants from their minds. This explains why the villagers are seemingly ignorant of a castle so close by and give the servants in the castle a more grounded and heartbreaking backstory, that their loved ones have genuinely forgotten them. The film paces well enough, giving Belle and The Beast an ample amount of time to get to know one another and fall in love for real, though I wish the first act spent more time on The Beast's more unsavory authoritarian behavior. The relationship with him and his servants is still an unclear one in this adaptation. In one moment they feel comfortable standing up to him, in another, they're frightened out of their minds. The boundaries are muddled. The rest of the plot goes along pretty much the same as the original with story beats either being extended or short-tailed in favor of something more innovative or relevant to today's times. This is very evident in Belle's feminist stances in the first act, such as her invention of the washing machine contraption so she can read in peace. The all-important ballroom sequence is as stunning in live-action, as it was in the revolutionary animation done over a decade before. It is a true moment of solidification of mutual attraction between two living beings, an affirmation of love and a promise of dedication, all executed in the form of a romantic candlelight waltz. The film is particularly grim in its climax, giving us a disturbing idea of what unhappily-ever -after looks like. The plot is nuanced enough to be considered new but does not divert enough from the source work to be regarded as a full out reinvention of the story itself. It is familiar and exciting in many of the right ways, and forgivable enough for its transgressions by making up for them with required aesthetic gloss and narrative aptitude.

A remake and a reimagining are distinctions that I believe must begin to take greater significance in regards to the cinematic arts. The word remake is becoming far too polluted and even vulgar when taken into many contexts by today's standards. It sounds reductive and ill-conceived. A reimagining is really what this film is, taking a well-known story and giving it a freshly concocted update without losing or devaluing what made it so invaluable in the first place. This new 2017 film does not disgrace the original, nor does it supersede it. Instead, it does what any remake or reimagining should honestly do; it honors it. Disney should always keep in mind when translating their larger than life stories into the real world that they must not lose the spirit of the original. Still, it also simultaneously has an obligation to build upon the source material's themes and create a memorable experience all anew for the audience. A film like this should leave the audiences with a conflicted, yet satisfying feeling in their hearts. A feeling that could only be described as "bittersweet and strange."

Friday, January 27, 2017

Sense 8: The Value of Interconnectivity in Today's Global Society



I have an immensely important announcement to make...

I
Have
Finally
Gotten
Netflix!




Yes, that is correct I am likely the last 20-Something American to finally join the many, the bingers, the Proud Netflix Users! Having been exceptionally late to the social media fiasco's that are Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, it was only right that I only now bring Netflix into my life. I had predicted what the effects of such a streaming service would have on me, and I can honestly say I was right. On day's I don't have work I sit, I write, I binge-watch. Stranger Things was the first show covered, and as I type this, I am already on the second season of The West Wing. Binging is quite a unique kind of viewing experience. It allocates a mental continuity to viewers that are unfortunately closed off from them during traditional television viewing. Binging allows us to tap into our insatiable primitive appetite for entertainment and our gluttonous impulses as consumers. Netflix has opened my mind and heart to so many incredible sources of entertainment and psycho-spiritual insight. The sentiment "better late than never" could never ring more true to my ears.


The second show I chose to binge-watch with my new Netflix account was the highly popular, but little discussed Netflix Original Series, Sense8. Sense8 is a show about eight diverse strangers from all around the globe who slowly begin to learn that they have a psychogenetic connection to one another. They can experience one another's physical and emotional sensations as well as tap into each other's various capabilities and skills. These people known as "Sensates" are being hunted by mysterious government figures who wish to lobotomize and ultimately eradicate their existence from this world. Sense8 is shot on location all around the world in places including Mexico City, Mumbai and South Korea. The cast is as international as the location shoots with each actor being indigence to the place in which their character resides, for the most part at least.  Sense8 alternates, continuously between eight different plot lines at a given time, and as the show progresses and the characters take a firmer hold of their unique abilities, these plotlines slowly, but inevitably begin to interweave with one another. Within these many plot lines, the topics covered are of a broad range including, law enforcement, Trans Rights, drug use, arranged marriages, female prison life and struggling with AIDS. Sense8 isn't done in the way of 7th Heaven or Glee's "Topic of the Week" style of storytelling. These topics run their course with relative consistency throughout the shows first season, and likely will continue to as the show goes forward. It is a television show about people, all kinds of people, living in various everyday circumstances with extraordinary abilities. Though their "extraordinary" abilities seem surprisingly realistic, likely because they are infused with realism, thanks to the talented cast and expert cinematographers.


Sense8 is a vitally important piece of entertainment at this current time in the world because it promotes the idea of a universal connectedness; a tangible string that ties us together despite our abundantly apparent differences. The show allocates a fair portion of its running time to allow each character's storyline a chance to make its plea for relevance to the audience, although sometimes the show's plea feels excessive. These actors are well-tuned and don't have to try very hard to gain our sympathy, though the writers occasionally waste running time in order to do just that. Long shots done simply to evoke a characters desperation or pain, can go a long way, but only if used sparingly. The show must keep working to find balance as it continues to juggle between the complex dynamics of the multi-narrative style it has laid before us. It must maintain this interconnectivity, especially now that the characters are much more aware of their unique situation and interact more with their fellow Sensates. Culture clashes are inevitable, but I firmly believe the show can and should handle them quite well, and without kid gloves or insult. It should also continue to build bridges of understanding between the various cultures and diverse lifestyles it depicts with great detail and superbly photographed set design. If more television shows, whether on Netflix or basic cable, took the groundbreaking chances that Sense8 does, maybe TV viewers would be an even more informed and culturally enriched bunch? Well, as I said earlier, better late than never.

Friday, December 30, 2016

Jackie (2016): Grief Embodied





In the last few months, the political climate has been profoundly perplexing to say the very least. It seems only fitting that a month and a half after this bizarre election, cinema allows us to turn back the clock to a different world of politics, one still complex, but elegant rather than crude in its complexity. Jackie (2016), however, is not a political film, nor should it be mistaken as one. It is a film that feels almost coincidently set in the world of politics rather than forcibly relying on it for drama. This is not about John F. Kennedy's Presidency, nor is it a film that is preoccupied with recreating a glossy version of his tragic assassination. In fact, this isn't even really a film about Jackie Kennedy when examined closely enough. While yes, the plot does detail her intimate struggles in the immediate aftermath of her husband's death, Jackie seems to stand in as a representation for something more substantial and perhaps even more resonating than a mere First Lady in mourning. Jackie's experiences in the days following the loss of her and this country's beloved King of Camelot is representative of how grief is capable of taking on a life of its own within a person.

The constant extreme close-ups and chilling score that carries an air of grandness with every violin stroke both do an extemporary job of detailing Jackie's personal strife as she comes to terms with life as a single mother, who has the eyes of the world glued to her every move. The movie is scattered, told non-sequentially as if to describe the distortion of mind and body that a mourner often elicits so soon after the death of a loved one. Jackie goes through stages of grief much like the way one watches the houses swoosh by while riding a train and looking out the window, with volatile and introverted enthusiasm.

Grief, at some point, becomes little about the person that has died and much about the mourner themselves. In Jackie, we catch Mrs Kennedy crying over the loss of herself and her continued worrisome plight that she's insufficiently capable of becoming someone new; Someone the public will still revere and admire. Natalie Portman imbues this performance with acts of both selflessness and selfishness. Jackie was far from one-sided, and Portman's portrayal allows her to be shown as the complicated multidimensional prism she was. Her witty quips and editorial notes to the journalist interviewing her prove that self-image was always a concern for her, First Lady or not. Still, however, it does not go unnoticed that the film has little to do with the Kennedy Legacy or even the legacy of this fine, often charismatic woman. No, Jackie excels because it makes the viewer feel in an all-too-real genuine manner the disturbingly cathartic sensation of human loss. Jackie Kennedy was truly grief embodied, but she refused to let this define her entire life. Those who suffer the loss of a great love one should take notice to do the same. When grieving you may allow it to take over you for a brief time, but true strength and growth is expelled once we take control of our grief and move on to tomorrow's harrowing journey, renewed and wiser than before—God Bless JFK, God Bless Jackie, and in a bizarre twist of emotion, God Bless Grief.



Friday, December 23, 2016

A Christmas Carol, a Christmas Story for the Ages.



There have been countless cinematic and television incarnations of Charles Dickens classic Christmas tale about a begrudged Christmas-hating miser, Ebenezer Scrooge. A Christmas Carol encompasses themes of greed, benevolence and the human capacity to love and be loved in return. While many esteemed actors from Albert Finney to Jim Carrey have portrayed the old grump, my personal favorite has always been George C. Scott's portrayal in the 1984's version of the story, brought to life on the screen by director Clive Donner. While Scott's version may not critically be considered the "best", I grew up watching it and after seeing many of the other versions, adamantly feel that this version of the tale resonates with me the most on a spiritual, emotional and psychological level. It's riddled with dry humor, dark subtext and moments of genuine warmth.

An interesting fact about this particular version of A Christmas Carol is a minor detail involving the wardrobe. In all the previous versions of the story (including the original novel), Scrooge is seen wearing a male nightgown and matching cap throughout the majority of the merrily eerie tale. George C. Scott, a prominent actor of the time, refused to parade around, sometimes in the winter snow, wearing pajamas! At his insistence, Scrooge wears his worn maroon suit during most of the film's running time. To a certain extent, Scott's pretentious wardrobe demand reinforces the essence of Scrooge's inner self. Scrooge is far too prideful and rigid to allow even a spirit to make him walkabout in his nightclothes. No, if he is going to have to face the facts of his tumultuous life, he shall do so in his business suit, calm and collected for however short a time. Yes, as he learns and discovers more about himself, it becomes tattered and tarnished, but it remains intact. While Scrooge does change, in the end, a part of him will always contain this external shell of his former self. A reminder of his past misdeeds which he must never repeat or risk facing the dire consequences. Scrooge's suit covers so much more than his body; it's an external representation of the façade he has put out onto the world. A poor reflection of his cold father, misguided business partner Marley and even his scorned long-ago lover, Belle. By Scott keeping it on throughout the film, Scrooge feels more ruthless and stifled and yet more human and conflicted as well.

A Christmas Carol may not be as visually appealing as The Nutcracker or as humorous as How The Grinch Stole Christmas, but it remains a timeless classic. I firmly believe this is because its message of love and appreciation of the power of the Christmas Spirit forever rings truth in the hearts of even the most stressed or strife-ridden holiday goer. Tiny Tim's sentiment, while occasionally overdrawn with emotional sentimentality is nevertheless accurate; "God Bless Us Everyone" yes, even those who may seem to lack any sort of merriment or jubilation in their candor, much like Mr Scrooge himself. God Bless them as well. Smile at these poor ignorant souls and remember at least, it's never too late for someone to change for the better. The holidays bring about an opportune time for such life improvement. Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to all!

And to those who hate movies...Bah Humbug!

Thursday, December 15, 2016

Nine: 9 Ways Movie Musicals Lose Their Way



Movie Musicals have been a part of cinema's history since soon after the innovation of sound on screen. They are spectacles of epic, yet often intimate stories told through song and dance. However, movie musicals are not the easiest films to write and produce. Execution of a top-quality movie musical requires a perfect storm of creative forces coming together at the right time with the right materials at their disposal. Nine (2009) came out in the winter of 2009 and was a movie musical based on a play (of the same name), that was also based on a movie, 8 1/2 (1963) . That's some pretty meta shit if you ask me.

Federico Fellini's semi-autobiographical story of Guido Contini, an esteemed Italian film director plagued by writer's block and the numerous women in his life, is a story of disparity and desire. It was no wonder that Rob Marshall, acclaimed director of the film version of Chicago (2002) chose to translate this tale back to the big screen. It has the glamour and glitz of any Hollywood blockbuster, which is also a part of its problem. The film, unfortunately, ended up falling severely short of expectations with both the critics and the box office. While the film has its many faults, it is still an enjoyable watch nonetheless, primarily thanks to its immensely talented ensemble cast. Where did the film go wrong? How do movie musicals that should be so easy to entertain, end up leaving us befuddled instead of bemused? I decided to use Nine as the test subject for this bewildering question.
Here are...

The Nine Do's and Don't of Movie Musicals.

9. Don't give it a complete rewrite.

If a musical is going from stage to screen, adjustments will need to be made so that the transition is smooth and effective. However, when the plot and story are changed too drastically, then the new version may get to the point that it feels reductive. The film version of Nine is not only altered greatly but is reduced to mere bones in certain areas of its skeletal story structure. This diminishes the psychological significance of the source material. You could also look at the film version of Rock of Ages (2012) to understand why complete story rewrites from stage to screen are a less than brilliant idea.

8. Do give the audience time to get to know the characters.

Movie Musicals are supposed to provide richly, memorable characters whose personal journey's are guided by music and dance. However, if the film is rushing to get to the singing and dancing before it gives us enough insight on who these people are and what they want out of life, the audience won't care what kind of songs they sing or how many tap dances they can do! Nine suffers from too short of a running time to give adequate enough character development to its characters. We have a brief introduction's to each before the singing starts, and they remain on screen for only a short time after. We catch fleeting glimpses into the lives of Guido and the women he loves, but we never watch them truly live and experience life.

7. Don't add characters unless they add significance.

While Kate Hudson is fabulous in her role as Stephanie in the film, she is essentially relegated to a glorified cameo as is the seriously underused Sophia Loren. Hudson's character is given little to nothing to do besides her 60's retro musical number "Cinema Italiano". She clearly represents temptation and Guido's insatiable lustful appetite, but she is not so much a character as she is a caricature. Her role could have easily been expanded had the writers been more thoughtful to how a female journalist may act and feel in a world dominated by powerful, successful men like Guido. Instead, she's more of a glossy groupie, and Kate Hudson already played that role much better in Almost Famous (2000). If your musical needs more characters, give them purpose, not just a glitzy costume and back-up dancers in sharp suits.

6. Do make good use of your setting.

This is something Nine got pretty right, its aesthetics. The use of the actual movie set as the setting for the musical numbers and the exquisite exterior shots of Rome in all its 1960's glory is extremely effective in setting the tone and vision for a film that's clearly about people obsessed with the visual images life has to offer them. Musicals are larger than life and Nine definitely resembles the renaissance of stylistic elegance that Italy was in the 1960's. That doesn't mean that the spaces are used well, only that they look good. 

5. Don't end on a whimper
"You Can't Stop The Beat", "We Go Together", Moulin Rouge's "Finale Medley". Musicals should end on a high note, pun intended. If possible the last song should be an ensemble number, because all of the storylines have come to fruition at this point in the climax. If the last song isn't a showstopper, it should have emotional resonance, a profound statement of change and evolution in the characters lives. Nine fails at this, giving Guido, and the women, only an orchestral accompaniment as they quite literally take their final bows in the film's conclusion. Yes, his wife is returning to him, and he has matured and grown, that's beautiful, but this is a musical for God's sake, sing about it!

4. Don't do clichés, unless they work.

Many musicals are campy at heart, and this is not a bad thing. It's an inevitability of a fantasy world of song and dance. Grease (1978) camps up the '50s and Hairspray (2007) certainly made full-blown campiness out of the '60s. Nine almost restrains itself too much. It shows its beautiful Italian setting with aplomb, but never really dives into its intimate innards. The studio-set where the musical numbers are featured feels artificial in the worst way. If every musical number had the campy energy of "Cinema Italiano" and "Be Italian", the movie would at least feel more fun. Musicals are meant to be made BIG!

  3. Do have a valuable message.

Musicals are not simply about singing and dancing just for the sake of it. Musicals are about an emotional build-up, about larger than life meanings and symbols being evoked through lyrical and rhythmic interpretations. If a musical has nothing to say, it doesn't matter how good the songs are or how mesmerizing the dance sequences are executed. Nine is a film that loses much of its meaning because the plot is significantly altered for the screen. The tale of a desperately conflicted man coming into his own with the aid of the underappreciated women in his life is itself undervalued and underwhelmed by glossy Hollywood melodrama.

2. Do contain, and take advantage of, chemistry amongst the cast.

Nine has a large ensemble of insurmountable talent, and from behind the scenes videos and cast interviews, it appears they all got on very well. On-screen, their chemistry is palatable enough, but unfortunately, most of the vibrantly talented women in the cast hardly get any screen time together. It's an unfortunate and unnecessary loss that if changed, could have helped elevate the film to greater depths.

1. Don't butcher the musical score!

Nine's greatest cinematic musical offense? The complete overhaul of the exquisite score Maury Yeston had created. The added songs don't do the film any wrong. "Cinema Italiano", "Guarda La Luna" and "Take it All" actually give the story more edges and curves rather than narrow it out into boredom. It is definitely a positive that Yeston, himself wrote the new songs. However, the film's story suffers greatly from Rob Marshall's poor misguided attempt at maintaining all the musical numbers inside the protagonist's head. It's even worse to know that several more numbers were filmed and then cut! Songs like "Simple" and "Getting Tall" give the plot of the musical its true meaning and invigorate audiences with the kind of passionate, poignant emotions one should feel when watching a musical of this stature. In the end, Nine cuts far too much and adds far too little to make up for it. It is simplified into insignificance, which is a shame because I believe its themes and messages have sizable weight to them. The musical score is the bone marrow of a musical, and it should be extracted and infused with great care and delicacy, for its implications are grand and purposeful. Nine may have missed the mark, but the incredible thing about musicals themselves is that they can still manage to entertain and bring delight even with faulty plot structures and mishandled musical scores. Musicals work on a level all their own.


Except for From Justin to Kelly (2003)....that movies just bad. In fact, it never happened.